“Equality of arms” in criminal procedure in the context of the right to a fair trial
Journal: RUDN Journal of Law (Vol.25, No. 3)Publication Date: 2021-08-24
Authors : Fardin Khalilov;
Page : 602-621
Keywords : criminal process; fairness; adversarial; equality of the parties; minimum rights; correlation; European Court of Human Rights; case law; interpretation;
Abstract
The level of realization of the right to a fair trial is one of the crucial indicators of democracy in any state. In order to ensure this right, all the minimum standards deriving from it must be clearly understood by law enforcement agencies and their practice must meet these standards. As ‘equality of arms’, the right to a fair trial, is not directly enshrined in the text of Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights (hereafter - the Convention) and is of implicit character; the issues like its essence, content and the way it should manifest in practice are open for discussion. For this reason, the focus on those issues is highly relevant. The aim of this article is, with reference to the case law of the European Court of Human Rights (hereafter - ECHR) and the modern doctrine based on this right, to explain the role of this principle and the essence of its mutual relations with the other elements of the right to a fair trial. Selected case law of ECHR bears great interest compared with other decisions and is discussed in the form of empirical materials of the study. From the doctrinal materials, interpretation of Article 6 of the Convention and theoretical sources related to the European standards in the criminal procedure are also analyzed. The article exercises methods of dialectical comprehension; they are determinism, induction, deduction, case studies and methods of law interpretation. As a result of the study, a unique doctrinal commentary has been obtained in the context of adversariality and impartial and independent court principles of the concept of ‘equality of arms’, as well as, interaction of the minimum rights of persons subject to criminal prosecution, guaranteed by the Convention.
Other Latest Articles
- Legal aspects of environmental safety in the field of medical waste management in the context of the pandemic
- Historical roots and current state of the “public - private law” issue in French legal doctrine
- Judicial practice in the law reality of Russia: experience of a comprehensive research
- Trade treaties of Russian and British empires with Yattishar: historical and legal study
- The concept of “strong state” in the political and legal dimension
Last modified: 2021-08-24 04:24:19