Legal consequences for the state arising from the use of weapons against civil aircraft: review and legal framework development
Journal: RUDN Journal of Law (Vol.25, No. 4)Publication Date: 2021-11-25
Authors : Tatiana Novikova; Stepan Kuts;
Page : 831-854
Keywords : aerial accident; international air law; principle of non-use of weapons against civil aircraft; security exception; self-defence; compensation; international civil aviation;
Abstract
The authors elaborate on one of the controversial issues of international air law - safety of civil aircraft in flight in respect of the use of weapons against it. The first part of the present article considers major aerial accidents arising from shooting down the civil aircraft for the last 70 years as a factual basis for further legal analysis. In the second part, the authors back up customary prohibition of the use of weapons against civil aircraft in flight and legal consequences for states for violating the mentioned principle. The authors investigate the grounds for the ‘security exception’ and conclude that the only grounds for derogation from the principle of non-use of weapons against civil aircraft is Article 51 of the UN Charter proclaiming the inherent right of the state to self-defence. Even in this case, the application of the ‘security exception’ by the state is tolerated by using a set of precautions before employment of weapons. Finally, authors conclude that compensation for victims reflects the inevitable monetisation of human lives. Moreover, states’ negotiations reveal the controversial reality of trade-offs between them, where compensation amounts are occasionally affected by external political factors and current position of a particular state in the international community.
Other Latest Articles
- Controlled foreign companies of Russian residents in the context of world trends
- Category of time limit in administrative procedural law
- Administrative regulations as a type of public administration acts
- The place of local government bodies in a unified system of public government bodies of Russia: issues of theoretical implementation
- High-tech law: concept, genesis and prospects
Last modified: 2021-11-25 04:30:43