Lessons Learned: The Complexity of Accurate Identification of in-Text Citations

The importance of citations is widely recognized by the scientific community. Citations are being used in making a number of vital decisions such as calculating impact factor of journals, calculating impact of a researcher (H-Index), ranking universities and research organizations. Furthermore, citation indexes, along with other criteria, employ citation counts to retrieve and rank relevant research papers. However, citing patterns and in-text citation frequency are not used for such important decisions. The identification of in-text citation from a scientific document is an important problem. However, identification of in-text citation is a tough ask due to the ambiguity between citation tag and content. This research focuses on in-text citation analysis and makes the following specific contributions such as: Provides detailed in-text citation analysis on 16,000 citations of an online journal, reports different pattern of citations-tags and its in-text citations and highlights the problems (mathematical ambiguities, wrong allotments, commonality in content and string variation) in identifying in-text citations from scientific documents. The accurate identification of in-text citations will help information retrieval systems, digital libraries and citation indexes.