Holodomor oral history: to question of interpretation of historical source
Journal: Manuscript and Book Heritage of Ukraine: Archeographic Studies of Unique Archival and Librarian Fonds (Vol.26, No. 26)Publication Date: 2020-10-22
Abstract
The goal of the research.The article aims to elaborate instruments of correla-tion between documents and oral history sources that deal with the Holodomor.Using contemporary approaches toward theoretical foundation of oral history, toapply them toward the Holodomor oral history from the point of view of their cre-dibility and validity. Methodology. The research uses historical-comparativist ap-proach that allowed separating common and distinctive features of documents and oral history sources in general and in particular (regarding the Holodomor). Also, method of deduction is used as a way to divide general (features of oral history in general) to parts (features of the Holodomor oral history). Scientific novelty. The article reveals strong and weak sides of the Holodomor oral history as a historical source. It shows that existing shortcomings, providing source criticism, like with any other historical source, can me minimized. Using examples of the Holocaust, Rwanda geno-cide and the Holodomor in Ukraine, the author analyzes their differences, suggests comparative characteristics of using oral history as information that has evidentiary value. Conclusions. The Soviet regime had destroyed part of official documentation, chronologically connected to 1930s. That is why oral history is irreplaceable for fur-ther research of the Holodomor and for overcoming of post-Soviet hypotheses about the causes of the famine (such as poor harvest, bad weather etc.). Respondents' age, traumatical nature of the event, fight of collective and individual memories, poorly organized passportization of oral history, mixing of two events in memory of re-spondents – famine of 1930-s and 1940-s is not an obstacle to use oral history. Juridi-cal value of oral history has been confirmed in Ukraine by initiating of a criminal case by the Security Service of Ukraine toward organizers of the genocide.
Other Latest Articles
- “Black boards” as repressive component of Holodomor on pages of Ukrainian regional press
- Documents of the Main Office for Science of the Rosenberg Office as Sources on the Ideological Component of Nazi Policy in the Occupied Territory of Eastern Europe during World War II
- Mass-circulation newspapers as integrated historical and bibliographic source and communication tool
- Publications on history of book culture and manuscriptheritage of Akademperiodika publishing house of National Akademy of Sciences of Ukraine in cooperation with V. I. Vernadskyi National Library of Ukraine
- Terminological key to study social and political thought in Russia (19th century)
Last modified: 2021-02-04 19:59:58